The EU is 100% wrong and you know it

I’m not a technical philosopher. I’m not a politician. I’m a coder. I deal with data and decision making processes and I work in small empowered teams usually in a bottom up organisational culture. The relevant buzzword – for what it’s worth – is “agile”. Things seem to work better in bottom up agile structures.

It only recently occurred to me that this observation about my professional life matches exactly my observations about politics. I felt a bit daft, if I’m honest, because the reason is the same in both cases: decisions are best left to the people directly involved.

In societies prices coordinate the whole. In groups of a few thousand at most, as in a corporation, hierarchical leadership structures coordinate. Both are mechanisms that to bring together the work of smaller groups, but it is small groups that get stuff done.

So how does this apply to the present controversy over EU membership? Well it’s frankly rather obvious:

The EU does not let decisions get made by the people directly involved. It preempts all their decisions centrally where most of the useful information – explicit and certainly implicit – is simply absent. It needn’t have been that way. It could have kept it’s activities to a minimum, met once a decade to update it’s tiny rule book and left us all alone – and still met it’s goal of preventing conflict and knocking down trade barriers (doing exactly nothing at all is perhaps the best method of facilitating trade).

Instead the EU represents top down leadership facilitated by a massive bureaucracy and complex impenetrable processes. I sympathise with their outright rejection of democracy because there is no way they could actually listen to voters on that scale. They have to ignore voters to give themselves a shot at making the right decisions. They are not – in a limited practical sense – wrong to do so, the problem is that the whole edifice is misconceived. As a libertarian I believe- and frankly it seems rather obvious – that decisions are made by the right people when made outside of political systems and by the wrong people when made inside political systems. This is because when small groups do stuff together it rarely involves either a national issue of any kind nor coercing people into agreement.

Coercion, in particular, is simply less important for successful cooperation than most people think. It is also a lot less nice than most people seem to appreciate. It amazes me that IT professionals, in particular, seem predisposed to vote for policies and constitutional arrangements that make use of coercion . If someone came into your office and told you that you MUST use Node.js, then however much you like Node.js you would question whether it was his job to make that decision. In politics there is a lot more at stake than broken code. The quality of decisions matters more in politics than in coding, yet coders seem willing to assume the role of a interfering suffocating chief architect.

For these reasons we should be moving more and more aspects of life outside of the scope of politics not moving more and more aspects of life into the control of a remote opinionated elite. The EU is a step in exactly the wrong direction. The EU, literally, could not be more wrong.

If you work in an agile team then you know this explicitly and you regularly push back on external interference. It’s time to apply your agile thinking to the rest of your life and start pushing back on June 23rd.

4 Comments

  1. Correct.

    A federated, distributed model is the way, and this is from someone who, amongst other things, owns certain central policy, standards, capabilities etc. for an entire organisation.

    A central team cannot scale, and the level of control would be totalitarian, stifling the emergence of new and potentially better methods.

    Supervision, not regulation.

    Like

    Reply

  2. Quite correct Simon – the European Union orders people about, it tells them how to live their lives (top down).

    It is additional layer of government (and the other layers are bad enough – without the E.U. in addition to them).

    One can understand why people who get (or hope to get) corrupt benefits from the E.U. (grants – or regulations to destroy their competitors with) would support the monstrosity that is the E.U, – but why do some other people support it?

    Fear – naked fear.

    The Spectator magazine disclosed back in January that Mr David Cameron’s campaign to keep us under the boot of the E.U was “Project Fear”.

    The point of the “Remain” campaign is to lie (let us be blunt – Mr Cameron and the other are lying) in order to whip up fear. The idea being that if people are made terrorfied they will cling to “Mother Europe” like frightened children.

    It is a disgusting tactic – organised by politicians (and others) who want to infantilize people, to make sure that people are under a government (the E.U.) they can not remove – and which seeks to control every detail of their lives “for their own good”.

    Remember that British politicians and officials, when people complain about regulations and order, can just say “it is an E.U. order – nothing can be done to change it, and voting us out of office would make no difference”.

    Please put a stop to that.

    Let us get out of the E.U.

    Like

    Reply

  3. You’ve convinced me.

    I am still worried about those who would see Brexit as a call for reduced trade and reduced immigration but that can’t be a reason to support something that is wrong.

    Like

    Reply

    1. Quite right. We might agree with some of the things a dictator says, but that doesn’t make us endorse dictatorship.

      Like

      Reply

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s