We’ll probably Remain in the EU

At the age of 20, my political views already formed, I followed the general election in Israel, the country I called home back then, very closely. Less than a year earlier the second intifada had reached its peak, with suicide bombings becoming a part of everyday life, until operation Defensive Shield set the Palestinian terrorists back somewhat.Then-leader of the opposition, Amram Mitzna of Labour (yes, Israel also enjoys a prominent Labour Party), suggested unilaterally ending the country’s military and civilian presence in the Gaza strip, if peace negotiations don’t yield a mutually agreed upon solution to the conflict.

Mitzna’s opponent, Prime Minister Ariel Sharon, strongly criticised this plan, arguing it would be a reward for terrorism, and would embolden Palestinian terrorists in their attacks on Israel, essentially sending them the message that if they attack, Israel would run.

This became the main issue in that year’s election campaign, and the Israeli people agreed with Sharon. They re-elected him by an overwhelming majority, giving his Likud Party twice as many seats as Labour (38 to 19 in Israel’s 120-member Parliament, the Knesset).

A few months into his second term, however, Sharon changed his mind. Not only was unilateral “disengagement” no longer a reward for terrorism, it was now such a good idea that it became Government policy. Sharon initially promised to hold a national referendum on the issue, and later changed his mind, deciding on a referendum of Likud Party members instead.

As a member of the party myself, I was very hopeful on the day of the vote. I truly believed that, were party members to reject the disengagement plan, it couldn’t possibly happen. After we won, with 65% of the vote, I felt great relief in the knowledge that “peace” would have to be achieved by some method other than the ethnic cleansing of Jews in Gaza.

Of course, after initially accepting the result, Sharon eventually carried out his plan, and today no Jews live in Gaza. The result of that decision can be seen in the Middle East today, but that is irrelevant to the point of this story.

Having lived through that, I find laughable the notion that the question of the UK’s membership in the EU has been “settled”. Winning a legally non-binding referendum by what both sides agree is a small margin, with the vast majority of MPs on the losing side, certainly creates a problem for Remain supporters. They need to find a way out of this ‘mess’. And they have.

While a Prime Minister from the Brexit camp would face an extremely difficult uphill battle, with pressures from the Remain side, the Leave side, EU bureaucrats and leaders of other European nations, for someone like Theresa May, these pressures could serve as a great opportunity to set the stage for keeping Britain a member of the European Union.

How she does it will largely depend on the aforementioned pressures; she could intentionally negotiate a bad deal, then call a second referendum in which Project Fear (which, worryingly and tellingly, has yet to end) will have a chance of swaying enough voters to tip the scales in favour of remain. She could also call a general election before the withdrawal is complete, and spin the result (whatever it is, other than perhaps a UKIP overall majority) as proof that the “public mood” has shifted.

Regarding any change that requires action by politicians as ‘done and dusted’ before it’s complete is naïve. Politicians spend a lifetime honing the craft of deceiving voters. There’s nothing most of them won’t pretend to care about, no apparent success they won’t take credit for, and no failure they won’t deny. If the remain side continues to protest the result as loudly as it has been so far, politicians will be convinced that ignoring the result, which they want to do anyway, could also benefit them in future elections. And once they view the situation that way, there’s nothing stopping them from keeping things as they are.

In Israel, we voted overwhelmingly against our disengagement, and the politicians made sure we got it anyway. For anyone who voted “leave”, if you want to make sure that this disengagement from the EU actually happens, please realise that the fight is nowhere near over.


  1. I agree with you that making Gaza “Jew free” did not bring peace – on the contrary it brought thousands of rockets and more pledges from the Islamists (the heirs of the Grand Mufti of Jerusalem in the early 20th century – the friend and ally of Mr Hitler) to exterminate Israel.

    However, with respect, I think you are wrong about the United KIngdom and the E.U. Britain will leave the E.U. – and the E.U. is going to collapse any way.

    However, I am voting for Andrea Leadsom (not Mrs May) – as Andrea Leadsom is far too publically committed to British independence to switch sides now. It is NOT the same position as Prime Minister Sharon – as Mr Sharon had his life in the army to use as “no one can question my patriotism” card to play (without even needing to formally say that).

    Mrs Leadsom has no life as war hero – no battle scars to show. Mrs Leadsom can not betray us – because to betray us is to destroy herself. The lady has no other foundation.

    But Mrs May? Well yes if Mrs May wins the leadership votes some trick will be pulled.

    Let us hope that the Italian banks collapse (taking the Euro and the E.U. with them) before that trick can be played.



    1. I agree that Theresa May is unlikely to ever have the political clout that Sharon had. But even considering that, and the other differences, both cultural and specific to the issues, politicians in all countries are generally cut from the same cloth; we all like to think our views matter, but I doubt they think that.

      Anyway, when I wrote this I was hoping we wouldn’t have to find out what May has up her sleeve. Now I can only hope I’m wrong.



Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s